Squint Test

If someone reads ONLY the headlines, they should understand the full value proposition.

HeroFeatures GridPainFAQCTA

Most visitors are scanners

Visitor tracking studies consistently show that most people don't read landing pages — they scan them. Eyes jump from headline to headline, pausing on anything that looks relevant and skipping everything else. Nielsen Norman Group has documented this pattern for two decades: the F-shaped reading pattern where visitors scan horizontally across the top, then vertically down the left side.

This means your body copy — the carefully crafted paragraphs below each headline — gets read by maybe 20% of visitors. The headlines get read by almost everyone. If your headlines don't carry the full message, 80% of your visitors miss it.

How to run the squint test

Literally squint at your page until the body text blurs and only the headlines remain readable. Now read top to bottom. Can you answer these three questions?

  1. 1.What does this product do?
  2. 2.Who is it for?
  3. 3.Why should I care?

If the answer to any of these is "not clear," you have a headline problem.

Here's what failing the squint test looks like: "The Modern Platform" → "Features" → "What People Say" → "Pricing" → "Ready to Start?"

You could put those headlines on literally any SaaS website. They communicate nothing about the product. Now compare: "See every SaaS subscription in one dashboard" → "Spreadsheets break when you hit 30 tools" → "Track, alert, and cut costs automatically" → "2,400 teams saved $12K+ last year" → "Start with 14 days free"

Same number of sections. Completely different information density. The second version tells a complete story in five headlines.

Headlines as a hierarchy

Think of your headlines as a hierarchy of information, like a table of contents for your product pitch.

H1 (hero): What the product does — the clearest, most specific version H2 (pain): Why the current solution fails H2 (features): What capabilities solve that problem H2 (proof): Evidence it works H2 (CTA): What to do next and why it's risk-free

Each headline level should build on the one before it. The visitor who reads only headlines gets the abbreviated pitch. The visitor who reads everything gets the full version. Both should be persuaded.

This is what PiratePage calls "structure before pixels." Get the headlines right, and the body copy and visual design become much easier — because you already know what each section needs to communicate.